AFL-CIO Logo
Search


Sign up for action alerts & news.

Update your e-mail.


Hear AFL-CIO Secretary-Treasurer Richard Trumka discuss how unchecked CEO pay contributed to the subprime mortgage crisis and the nation's economic crisis. iTunes

this will be replaced by the SWF.

Urge your senators to support
Say on Pay

RED BULLET  Take Action  RED BULLET  Learn More
Make your voice heard on the mortgage meltdown
RED BULLET  Take Action  RED BULLET  Learn More
Countrywide Financial Case Study

* The AFL-CIO Total is calculated as originally proposed by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in its initial 2006 rule making on executive compensation disclosure. On Dec. 22, 2006, the SEC amended the disclosure rules for stock options and other equity awards. Under this change, companies are required only to include the value of equity awards that vest during the fiscal year instead of the full value that is granted to executives. The SEC Total follows the approach used by the Financial Accounting Standards Board in determining the amount of options to be expensed in a company’s financial statements. In order to show the full value of equity awards granted to executives, the AFL-CIO Total includes the Grant Date Fair Value of Stock and Options Awards as found in the Grants of Plan-Based Awards table of the company’s proxy statement. The AFL-CIO believes this total calculation better represents the full value of compensation awarded to executives as decided by the board of directors during the fiscal year in question. The AFL-CIO Total follows the method the SEC has historically used in disclosing options granted to executives.

 

Countrywide Financial Corp., once the nation’s biggest home lender, which originated more than $450 billion in mortgages annually, or about one-fifth of all home loans,[1] embodies the subprime mortgage crisis more than any other company.[2]

“It seems like CEOs hit the lottery even when their companies collapse,” said Rep. Henry Waxman, the California Democrat who chairs the U.S. House Oversight and Government Reform Committee, at the March 7 hearing on CEO pay and the mortgage crisis. No CEO epitomizes that better than Countrywide Chairman and Chief Executive Officer Angelo Mozilo.

At the mortgage lender, stock-option compensation rewarded executives for short-term stock performance even while they pushed lending practices that were not sustainable over the long run. During the height of the real estate bubble between 2004 and 2007, Mozilo cashed in on these short-term gains by exercising stock options valued at $414 million, prompting an informal U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) investigation into the sales.[3] As a result, he already had pocketed a tidy profit by the time the long-term consequences of his decisions finally caught up with the company’s share price.

In 2004, Countrywide became the largest U.S. mortgage lender, in part, by using aggressive sales techniques and by lowering lending standards.[4] Like other lenders, Countrywide also introduced exotic mortgages that allowed borrowers to qualify for larger mortgages. As the housing boom peaked in 2005, an increasing percentage of Countrywide’s borrowers were sold “pay option ARMs,” a nontraditional mortgage the lender first offered to its borrowers in 2001.[5]

A pay option ARM is an adjustible rate mortgage loan that allows the borrower a choice of payment methods, including a minimum payment option that is less than the interest owed. Borrowers who select the minimum payment option have the difference between the interest they owe and the interest they actually pay added to their outstanding loan balance each month in a situation known as “negative amortization.” Over time, borrowers who pay the minimum payment also face elevated interest rates.[6]

As the real estate bubble deflated in the second half of 2007, Countrywide suffered $1.6 billion in mortgage-related losses. By the end of the year, more than 5 percent of Countrywide’s $28.42 billion in pay option ARMs were at least 90 days overdue and 71 percent of its pay option ARM borrowers were making minimal payments. Countrywide also disclosed that only about one-fifth of its borrowers had fully documented their incomes before receiving the loans.[7]

In August 2007, deteriorating credit market conditions forced Countrywide to seek outside financial help by selling $2 billion in convertible shares to Bank of America. As the mortgage credit crisis worsened, Countrywide risked losing both its investment-grade rating and also violating its bank loan covenants. In January 2008, Countrywide announced a $4 billion merger with Bank of America, at a loss of $20 billion in market value from the previous year.[8]

Before this end-game transpired, Mozilo had doggedly bargained a very lucrative employment agreement at the end of 2006, despite the vocal criticism it received. In fact, in an e-mail to Countrywide’s compensation consultant, Mozilo complained that “Boards have been placed under enormous pressure by the left-wing, anti-business press and the envious leaders of unions and other so-called “CEO Comp Watchers.”[9] At the time, Mozilo also proposed to collect a $3 million pension while he remained an employee of Countrywide.[10]

On the Friday before Christmas 2006, Mozilo and Countrywide finalized his new employment agreement. The annual pay terms included a base salary of $1.9 million, an incentive bonus of between $4 million to $10 million, an equity award of $10 million and continuation of Mozilo’s other perks and fringe benefits. The new contract also promised him the $37.5 million in severance benefits.[11]

But when the financial success that made it possible for him to get such an employment agreement proved so fragile that the entire company had to be sold at a fraction of its previous market capitalization, Mozilo could no longer avoid making some concessions. Facing growing public criticism, Mozilo announced that he would voluntarily give up his $37.5 million golden parachute that he would receive when Bank of America completed its acquisition of Countrywide.[12] Reflecting the changed financial conditions, the company also canceled its plans to host a ski trip for mortgage bankers at the Ritz-Carlton ski resort in Avon, Colo., where rooms start at $725 a night. The itinerary reportedly included dinner at Spago, the famous restaurant whose menu includes Kobe steak as an entrée for $105.[13]

But Mozilo will not be leaving Countrywide empty-handed. He is entitled to an enhanced supplemental executive retirement plan with a lump sum worth $22.4 million, a pension plan with a present value of $1.3 million and $20.6 million in deferred compensation.[14] And while Countrywide shareholders have seen the value of their investment fall 85 percent since February 2007, Mozilo also will keep his $414 million in stock options that he exercised between 2004 and 2007. On top of that, Mozilo, who intends to retire after Bank of America Corp.’s (BAC's) pending takeover of Countrywide this year, will receive $10 million worth of stock in BAC, according to filings with the SEC.[15]

 


[1] “FBI Investigates Countrywide,” The Wall Street Journal, March 8, 2008

[2] “Countrywide Seeks Rescue Deal,” The Wall Street Journal, Jan. 11, 2008.

[3] “Countrywide Seeks Rescue Deal,” The Wall Street Journal, Jan. 11, 2008.

[4] Testimony of Angelo Mozilo before the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee, March 7, 2008.

[5] “New Rules for ‘Exotic’ Loans,” The New York Times, Oct. 15, 2006.

[6] “Countrywide's Mortgage Woes Deepen,” The Wall Street Journal, March 3, 2008.

[7] “Behind Bank of America's Big Gamble,” The Wall Street Journal, Jan. 12, 2008.

[8] E-mail from Angelo Mozilo to John England, Oct. 20, 2006, released by the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee.

[9]E-mail from Angelo Mozilo to John England, Nov. 23, 2006, released by the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee.

[10]Countrywide Form 8-K filed with the SEC on Dec. 23, 2006.

[11]Countrywide CEO Forfeits $37.5 Million as He Exits,” The Wall Street Journal, Jan. 28, 2008.

[12] “Countrywide Cancels Ski Trip Amid Criticism,” The Wall Street Journal, Feb. 26, 2008.

[13]Countrywide Proxy Statement filed with the SEC on April 27, 2007.

[14] “Countrywide CEO, Pres. to Receive Combined $19 million in Stock,” The Wall Street Journal, March 29, 2008.

[15] “Countrywide CEO, Pres to Receive Combined $19 million in Stock,” The Wall Street Journal, March 29, 2008.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
Copyright © 2009 AFL-CIO | American Federation of Labor - Congress of Industrial Organizations Contact Us | Union Jobs | Privacy Policy | Site Map