|
Detroit Local 94
Members:
We have compiled the following
information to answer some of your immediate questions about our
new bargaining agreement, the equity claim and buyout
distribution delays. We will do our best to keep you
updated as the situation evolves and additional information
becomes available. Please remember our monthly DTW base
meeting scheduled for this Wednesday, June 13th at 1:00
p.m. (See agenda posted at the end of this
e-mail.)
Important
Reminder Regarding 401(k) Contribution
Changes
Many Flight Attendants have made adjustments to their
401(k) contributions in anticipation of the equity claim check,
but do not want these changes to continue on their 27th
paycheck. The deadline to change your 401(k) contribution
in time to affect your June 27 paycheck is 1500 CDT on Friday,
June 15, 2007. Call (800) NWA-SAVE Monday through
Friday between 7 a.m. and 7 p.m. Central Time or access the
website at https://nwa401k.csplans.com/portal/PortalLogin.jsp
. You can also access your 401(k) account via RADAR by
clicking on 'Pay and Benefits' and then 401(k).
Our Contract is in Effect -
This is Only a Delay for the Equity Claim, Early
Out, Etc. Some flight attendants have asked whether our new
contract in effect or not, and if it is, why is only the equity
claim and some of the other money delayed? Let’s be
absolutely clear about this: the Green Book was ratified and our
new contract is in effect.
For legal reasons, we have had
to delay the distribution of the equity claim money (approx.
$116 million), the early out money (approx. $32 million), etc.
on the remote chance the challenge by Guy Meek overturns the
election. It’s not because those provisions are no longer
in effect, but rather, it’s because if the money were
distributed and later the challenge were to overturn the vote it
would almost be almost impossible to undo nearly $150 million in
payments. The last thing we need is for the Company to then
demand that the flight attendants return all that
money.
There’s also a legal risk, in the remote
chance that the election is overturned, that might prompt the
Company or even other creditors to sue the union or sue all the
individual flight attendants to recover the equity claim money.
AFA Legal would, of course, aggressively defend against any such
lawsuit, but with the huge amounts of money involved here the
only prudent course is to delay the distribution until the
challenge is resolved, or until it’s withdrawn by Mr.
Meek.
Unless and until the election is overturned we
still have a contract. Meanwhile, the Negotiations
Committee continues to work through implementation issues with
the Company’s negotiators. Some items have been
implemented retroactive to June 1, others will be implemented at
the beginning of the July bid month. Details are being provided
by the Negotiations Committee as they are hammered out. The
Grievance Committee is also working under the new contract,
filing grievances as necessary.
The contract is in place
and although we have every confidence in the voting process and
it is very unlikely that the vote will be overturned, we cannot
pre-judge the investigation. If Mr. Meek submits any evidence
AFA is obligated to investigate. He has not submitted any
evidence yet; however, he has until June 22 to do so.
AFA’s Ballot Certification Committee will act promptly to
complete the investigation. After that it’s up to Mr. Meek
and Mr. Ibarra to decide whether to pursue the legal action they
have threatened, or to accept the results of the investigation,
and the results of the election, end the dispute and thus allow
the money to be distributed.
Questions and Answers about the Delay of the Equity
Claim and Related Issues
Q. How long is this delay likely to
take?
A. That will depend on what Guy
Meek and Jose Ibarra do next. AFA has given Mr. Meek until June
22, 2007 to submit evidence to support his allegations. If he
submits the evidence sooner, then the investigation will start
and end sooner. The investigation will take about 1 to 2 weeks
after we receive the evidence, if any. If Mr. Meek and Mr.
Ibarra then decide to pursue a legal appeal into the courts,
that could take months, and the funds would likely still need to
be held back in order to avoid any legal risk that the court
would order flight attendants to return the money. It is our
hope that this matter will be resolved, or withdrawn by Mr.
Meek, quickly so that the funds can be released to the flight
attendants.
Q. Why do we have to allow Guy Meek to
delay the distribution?
A. When we received Mr. Meek's
challenge we immediately sent it to our in-house Legal
Department. Their first assessment was that there is no merit to
the allegation whatsoever. Nevertheless, a member is entitled to
assert such a challenge and we must follow the procedures of the
AFA Constitution and Bylaws and Policy Manual and investigate
whether there is "due cause" to overturn the
election.
Our attorneys also consulted with
our outside bankruptcy and corporate lawyers to seek their
advice. Because of the magnitude of the money involved, even the
very slightest possibility of the ratification being overturned
requires us to ensure that the entire equity claim distribution
(and the Early Out / Surplus Severance Payment) is delayed. If
the money were distributed, our attorneys advise us that the
union and the individual members who receive the money could
later be sued by the Company or by other creditors from the
bankruptcy case in an attempt to recover the money if the
challenge succeeds in overturning the results of the vote. This
is very disappointing to us, and I am sure to the vast majority
of those who were counting on receiving this money at a
specified time. It is our hope that this matter will be quickly
resolved, or withdrawn by Mr. Meek, so that the funds can be
distributed to the flight attendants.
Q. If the challenge is without
foundation, as I believe it is, what steps will be taken to seek
personal damages against Mr. Meek and Mr. Ibarra for the loss
that their action is immediately causing to each
employee?
A. With the threat of litigation
already being announced, it's not appropriate to discuss
possible future legal action taken on behalf of the Union and
our members. The best outcome would be for this matter to be
resolved without litigation so the funds could be distributed to
the flight attendants as soon as possible. AFA will conduct a
thorough and fair investigation, and we will aggressively defend
the Union and our members in court if Mr. Meek, Mr. Ibarra or
others decide to file a lawsuit to delay this matter further.
Our goal is to get the money distributed.
Q. Will we, the employees, be
responsible for returning to the company the money received from
the sale of the stock plus the 35% difference between the face
value of the stock and the price at which the stock was sold if
the affirmative vote is set aside?
A. Our position would be that we
had a ratified agreement at the time the claim was sold and are
not required to repay any of the money, and certainly not the
original $182 million. That claim was rightfully sold for
approximately $116 million. However, if the vote were overturned
the Company or the other creditors might take a different
position. That's why the money is now being held in an
interest-bearing account for the benefit of the flight
attendants. The distribution is being delayed –even though
we believe there is only a remote chance that Mr. Meek's
challenge would overturn the vote results –because
overturning this vote after the money is distributed would
potentially have enormous financial and legal consequences. This
delay avoids a potential lawsuit against the Union and against
the individual members who would receive those funds in the
event the Company or other creditors would seek the return of
those funds if the vote is overturned.
LOCAL EXECUTIVE COUNCIL 94
MEETING
Wednesday, June
13, 2007, 1:00 p.m.
AFA-CWA Union
Office
(under
gate 8, take the elevator to the apron level and follow the
signs)
Agenda Topics:
·
Governmental Affairs - Diana Mitchum, MEC AFA Governmental
Affairs Vice Chair
· EAP
Presentation - Sally Lukas, MEC AFA EAP Chair
·
Grievance Committee Update - Patricia Reller, LEC 94 Grievance
Committee Chair
·
Upcoming AFA Northwest Airlines Master Executive Council
Elections
· Late
Agenda Items
In Unity,
Your DTW Local 94
Council
|